Monthly Archives: February 2011

Skinny Fat

Fat scale

You can be fat and still be healthy.

A couple of weeks ago, I replied to Stranger writer Lindy West’s fat-claration and made the point that no matter your weight, BMI,  body fat percentage, etc. the ultimate goal of any diet and weight loss regimen should be good health, something that is a bit less quantifiable than a number on a scale.

So I wanted to show you some examples of what it means to be unhealthy. Since I’ve spent so much time blogging about unhealthy fat people on A&E’s “Heavy,” today I’d like to focus on unhealthy skinny people, better known as “skinny fat,” instead.

Cheesy Blasters

Skinny fat people, I know your weakness.

Skinny fat people are precisely what you think: skinny people who look fit with their clothes on, but naked they are anything but, all squishy around the middle and without any muscle definition. Skinny fat people are sedentary and don’t eat well. They were simply blessed with high metabolism and the right genes. (Lucky bastards. Okay… maybe I’m just a little bitter.)

Skinny fat people can eat anything–favorites include Mountain Dew, cheese doodles, frozen foods with brightly-colored packaging, like Cheesy Blasters–and don’t gain a pound even though they veg out with the PS3 or watch re-runs of “Buffy” every night. Despite their sedentary lifestyles, somehow they ward off fat, or so that’s how we perceive them, until the clothes come off, and we see they are more jiggle than ripple, too.

Some examples of skinny fat include:

 

skinny fat man
Skinny Fat Specimen #1
Skinny fat woman
Skinny Fat Specimen #2

Neither of these bodies are obese by BMI standards (In case you didn’t know, I hate BMI.), but they both have no visible muscle mass, which can be attributed to a lack of strength training or undereating. (The body burns muscle first when it doesn’t get enough calories to function.) Being skinny fat is about as bad for the body as being fat fat since skinny fatties are susceptible to heart disease, diabetes and other health problems generally associated with being overweight. Their fatness may not be as visible as your standard fat person, but skinny fat people have a disproportionate ratio of body fat to lean muscle mass, leading to fat accumulation around the vital organs, as you can see in the pictures above. The two specimens are storing the fat they do have in all the wrong places.

So what’s a skinny fat person to do? Pretty much the same things a fat person would do (except less cardio because, without strength training and a proper diet, it won’t help you build muscle as quickly): eat better, more protein-packed meals and exercise with an emphasis on building muscle, meaning lots of weight training.

And, sorry–no more Cheesy Blasters!

Feel Free to Slap Me in the Face

Brian McGuigan

This looks like the face of a man that may slap you, but would he run in order to slap you? I'm skeptical.

A few mornings ago I woke up to an email from my friend Steve with that as the subject line: feel free to slap me in the face.

Steve isn’t exactly someone you’d slap in the face. He’s a self-proclaimed “quiet Canadian” who would only ever insult you to the point of deserving a face-slapping when he’s Tucker Max Drunk. And the next day, he’d be grossly embarrassed and apologetic, as you would expect of a card-carrying member of the Nice Guys Brigade. (They have a Facebook page, you know.)

So, of course, when I saw the email, I was intrigued and opened it immediately. Any email sent at 12:10 a.m. with a subject line like that has to be good, I thought.

Here’s what Steve wrote, including typos (Because it wouldn’t be a post-midnight email from Steve without typos.) and a few comments from me in brackets and minus names and a few sordid details:

On July 17th there is a 5K in Seattle. Let’s run it together.

When [REDACTED: the name of a busybody friend who's always giving Steve unsolicited and unwanted advice] tries to say shit to me I get pissed and I wonder why she even thinks I care what she has to say. So, if this is like that, Tell
me to shut the fuck up. I did some math and I think I know how you can
be in proper shape to run it though.

Today is 2/23 [Technically, it was 2/24, but only by 10 minutes...]

You said you hit 45 minutes on the elliptical

These are just dates with minutes you can do on the elliptical  and
treadmill. I don’t think distance even matters. Just as long as you
can do these things for this amount of time by July you’ll be ready as
fuck for a 5K. And let me tell you, one of the advantages of being in
the back is all the ass you get to look at. Your life might be changed
from running after 200 asses in tight shorts, fuck the weight loss and
health, ass, [REDACTED: think of a word that would insult your sensibilities beyond belief and insert that word here.].

dates and goals

3/31
1 hour on the elip
4/15
15 on the elip
15 on the tredmil
4/30
20 on the elip
20 on the tred
5/15
15 elip
25 tred
5/30
10 elip
30 tred
6/15
5 elip
35 tred
5 elip
6/30
35 tred
10 elip
7/15
45 tred

7/16 – Rest!

7/17 we do a mother fucking 5K!

I know I’m a chain smoking drunk, but I do know cardio. [REDACTED: Personal confession that may or may not result in an intervention for Steve, or, at least, interfere with his ability to get hired anywhere in the greater Seattle-area. By the way, if you're hiring, I know someone...]

And if I overstepped my bounds, i didn’t mean too, i’m just drunk and [REDACTED: participating in an assortment of criminal activities too heinous to mention in this post.]

————–

Run, Forrest, Run!

Forrest Gump hates fat people.

For the last few days, I’ve been seriously considering the offer/challenge of running a 5K. Running has never been something I’ve enjoyed. Since my days as a Truffle-Shuffling fat kid, I’ve always been hyper-aware of my body when in frequent and sustained motion, like running, because often the sight of my fleshy behemoth core inspired people to shout “Earthquake!” or “Stampede!” or, the most cliche of all, “Run, Forrest, Run!” (For the record, I have had no known impact on the Richter Scale.)

Even when I first began working out, cardio interested me the least, in part because I feared judgment but also because treadmills and other cardio machines made me feel like a really fat hamster working that wheel until it was cheese time.

fat hamster

Where the cheese at?

Over time, I’ve developed a love-hate relationship with cardio, which recently has been more on the love side since I lost 30 lbs. last year just by walking home from work and Wii Fit-ing my ass off in the mornings a few days a week. (Nintendo, again, hit me up about that spokesman gig.) Since my relationship with cardio has been more positive recently, the 5K seems like a good opportunity to test our bond, to see if cardio and I were truly meant to be.

But, first, I’m curious if you’ve ever run one before and, if so, do you have any tips for a fat fuck seriously considering a 5K? Lay it on me. I promise not to slap you in the face.

Heavy: Episode 6

oxygen mask

Keep this up, "Heavy," and you're going to need an oxygen mask.

Episode 6 of “Heavy” was different than all the others in so many ways. The clients were taken to a new facility (the Hilton Head Health in South Carolina) where they stayed for six full months rather than the usual one and then five more at home. Like “Intervention,” there was more of a focus on the health risks of obesity, yet the show lacked the in-depth look at the clients’ home lives, which is why this post won’t touch on them, like my others have. The clients were also allowed to email, text and use the phone and didn’t have their bags openly examined by the trainers, who were not David or Britny anymore.

Production-wise, the episode was pilot-level, at best. In fact, halfway through, I was convinced it was a knock-off of the show I’ve grown to love, some amateur film student’s attempt to recreate A&E’s popular new series. But despite the differences, one aspect of “Heavy” was business as usual: two very overweight people, Ronnie, a 437.6 lb. 44 year-old father of three, and Debbie, a 401.4 lb. 44 year-old virgin (Yes, you read that right.), were on the show for a reason: to change their lives.

Ronnie, much like Ashley and Flor before him, arrived at “the facility” in full-on “beast mode,” confessing before he left “I’m not even a hero to my kids anymore.” Ronnie was used to being everyone’s hero. Twenty-five years ago, he was a high school and college football star, a muscular, athletic man with the world in his hands. Then his mother was diagnosed with cancer, and Ronnie’s world completely changed. He went from being a man the world, or at least his town, revolved around to being a man whose world revolved around a dying woman. Ronnie became his mother’s caregiver, managing all aspects of her life, including cooking for her. As he watched his mother dying, he began using food as a method of coping with her loss, remarking “[her death] changed my life…turned me into 450 lbs.” Once a coping mechanism, Ronnie’s eating quickly turned into an addiction, one that caused him to have alarmingly high blood pressure and cholesterol levels. His addiction was so bad he would eat until he threw up, but more importantly, it was affecting his relationship with his kids and his fiance Cara, a wonderfully supportive and loving woman, whose mother had been diagnosed with cancer, too, prompting Ronnie to become the caregiver for his kids and hers and supplying him with yet another trigger to eat. But Cara was at the end of her rope and threatened to end her relationship with Ronnie because she and her family were “tied to what he can’t do vs. what all of [them] can.”

Burger King's King

That King is a sexy beast indeed.

While Ronnie basically had the support of his entire town, Debbie wasn’t so lucky. Not only was she a virgin, but she had absolutely no confidence in herself. Debbie became heavy at an early age, and once she was in high school, she learned quickly that there was no rejection in food, like there was with relationships. While her friends were out meeting boys, Debbie’s “boyfriend was McDonalds, Burger King.” She “didn’t feel worthy enough to have somebody love [her],” and as she gained weight, she began feeling more and more hopeless about her ability to find someone, saying “I just feel like my body is disgusting.” (Apparently, Debbie hasn’t heard Chris Rock’s thoughts on the negotiating powers women inherently have.) Debbie had become embarrassed by her weight, and it wasn’t only affecting her ability to have a relationship, she couldn’t even play golf anymore, something she used to do with her father regularly, because she couldn’t walk and struggled to swing a club. As Debbie said before arriving at “the facility,” it was time for her to make a “definite change.”

Now here’s where episode six of “Heavy” took a downturn for me. Upon arriving at “the facility,” we learn that Ronnie and Debbie will be there for six months rather than the usual one month with an additional five at home where they would further assimilate and make adjustments to their home life based on the healthier lifestyle they had been living at “the facility” with close monitoring by David and Britny, who were also gone in exchange for Amber the trainer, who we barely see working with the clients; Beverly, a tough-talking trainer/life coach who seems like the new David, just without all the muscle; and Adam, the fitness director who orchestrates the most awkward scene in the short history of “Heavy.” Neither Ronnie nor Debbie weigh-in with the trainers present, establishing a disconnected, less personal support system that made both clients resonate less with me.

Despite my qualms, Ronnie and Debbie still had weight to lose, and they both did it, but rather, well, differently (I’m sorry for making “different” the buzzword of this post, but, really, the episode was.) Ronnie, arriving in “beast mode,” was determined to lose 200 lbs., an amount of weight that seemed completely unhealthy to lose in six months. Within his first month at “the facility,” his “football mentality” inspired Ronnie to go hard, too hard actually, causing him to injure his knee. (I posted yesterday about my own competitive spirit and how that has caused me to overdo it, like Ronnie.) But, as Ronnie said, he’s “always pushed through injuries,” and he did, amassing a 97.2 lb. weight loss at the three-month mark. However, he wasn’t willing to address the underlying issues of his food addiction with the counselors at “the facility,” so when Cara visited him, she and Beverly teamed up on Ronnie, insisting that he talk to the counselor. Ronnie put up a fight, but Beverly got all David on him, accusing him of being in denial and saying, “You know how to lose weight, but you don’t know shit about keeping it off.” Ronnie finally relented and began addressing his addiction issues.

David Richardson

I'm starting the campaign: bring back David Richardson! But first, he'll need to wear more than that wash rag over his junk.

Debbie wasn’t quite as dedicated as Ronnie. From the first day, she fought Amber and Beverly, but not because she was necessarily combative, Debbie just didn’t believe in herself. She refused to do push-ups–even the granny-kind–because she didn’t think she’d be able to get up. After a few days, the trainers finally called her on it, but Debbie promised, “I’m doing what I can do.” Amber and Beverly pushed, yet not too hard knowing that, despite her lack of belief in herself, Debbie still needed to be in control. And by the halfway point, she had certainly made a dent losing 55 lbs. But Debbie’s weight wasn’t her only problem. Remember: she was a virgin at 44 and not because she was saving herself for marriage. Debbie says she just hadn’t met the right guy; however, after listening to her continuously doubt herself and be unwilling to push, it’s clear that the problem was her confidence. Debbie wasn’t willing to try because she feared failure. So Adam, the fitness director at “the facility,” got the bright idea to simulate a scenario where Debbie might strike up a conversation with a single man at a place she loves: the driving range. Unfortunately, there’s no video online yet, but trust me when I tell you: this scene was incredibly awkward, Adam trying to convince Debbie that she could pick up someone at the golf course by striking conversation about the person’s swing and Debbie finally insisting that she wouldn’t talk to anyone because “when you’re golfing, you concentrate on golfing. You don’t want talk a lot.” Obviously, this scene made me truly miss David and Britny.

The final weigh-in lacked the drama of previous episodes, as Ronnie and Debbie simply hopped on the scales and weighed in as they had at the 7, 90 and 150 day markers. Debbie’s final weigh-in was 269.8, a total weight loss of 130.6 lbs. She looked–yes, you guessed it–different, but, despite losing more than any other woman on “Heavy,” Debbie seemed like the same person, lacking the quintessential shine of someone who lost about a third of their body weight. Of course, Ronnie’s final weigh-in was–here it comes!–different than Debbie’s. He finished his six-months at “the facility” at 264.8, a total of 172.8 lbs., the most significant weight loss yet. The final weigh-in may have lacked the drama of the preceding episodes, but Ronnie was sure to step it up by following through on the pledge he made when he arrived: to run a minute for every pound he lost. And Ronnie did it, running three hours straight, and when he finished, due to both exhaustion and emotion, he choked up, realizing he’d come farther than the treadmill could even count.

Despite the dramatic reveals, episode six was, without a doubt, the most disappointing episode of “Heavy.” It lacked the sincerity of the previous episodes, but mostly, it missed the personal touch, either through the stories of how Ronnie and Debbie came to be so overweight (Debbie was a 44-year-old virgin. Are we really supposed to believe it was because she was socially awkward? There has to be much more to it than that.) or the personal connections each made with the trainers, who didn’t quite have the personality or the overall chutzpah of David and Britny. With six months at “the facility,” both clients had more dramatic reveals than in previous episodes, but that didn’t help them implement healthy behavior into their lives. The previous episodes made it clear that weight loss can be hard, but keeping it off is the real challenge, a point that really wasn’t  made besides Beverly’s curt snap at Ronnie. Under the new fitness regimen, I really don’t think the weight loss for either Ronnie or Debbie will be sustainable, as evidenced by the follow-up at the end of the episode where three months later Ronnie and Debbie had simply “maintained” their weight loss.

“Heavy” producers, if you’re reading this, please bring back David, Britny and the original format of the show. It could change your lives, or, at least, save your show.

Brian McGuigan is a writer, performer and arts get-shit-done-er working on a one-man show about his own struggles with weight loss entitled “Fat Fuck.” He blogs weekly about A&E’s new docu-drama “Heavy” at brianwithani.com.

I Was Outlifted by a Girl

Rice Krispies

Put your ear to that, and you'll hear my shoulder popping.

Yes, it’s true. This morning as I bench pressed the most I have since my shoulder made a noise you’d expect of Rice Krispies bathing in milk about six years ago I looked to my right and saw a woman about half my weight benching more than me. This isn’t intended to be sexist, but someone half my size–woman or man–shouldn’t be able to outlift me. At least, that’s what I’ve always thought.

Six years ago, I would have taken this as a challenge and pushed myself beyond my limits. After all, that’s how I hurt myself in the first place and spent several years in pain, put on 80 lbs. and fell into a fat hole only Wii Fit could pull me out of. (Nintendo, contact meI could be a Wii Fit spokesperson. For real.) But instead of feeling like the lesser man, I just kept on benching, knowing that I need to build my strength up before I can outlift anyone–even this little lady.

Overdoing it when working out can be a problem. We see someone else do something and think we can, too, until we try and fail but, more importantly, put ourselves in danger of injury. I’ve had all too many moments at the gym where I’ve seen someone lift more, run faster or do more reps, and my competitive spirit automatically kicks in, causing a little voice that sounds like a mash up of 50 Cent and “Predator” to tell me, “Don’t be a pussy.”

What I’ve learned though is that little voice can motivate me just as easily as it can demotivate–or injure–me, and instead of beating myself up, I should focus on what weight seems right for me and gradually work my way up. So when working out, know your limits, take it there, but be careful. You don’t want to end up like this guy.

Sharon from Episode 3…

commented on my blog!

Sharon on the bicycle

I can't ride a bike, but I'm happy Sharon can.

Although she calls me “David with an I,” (Can you even spell David with a letter besides I? That just seems… wrong!) Sharon’s comment is really sweet and supportive of my work recapping this season’s “Heavy” episodes. She offers some reflection on her episode, too. My favorite part was one of hers as well. She writes: “I have to admit that one of my favorite scenes in the show was the bicycle scene too! It was impossible to wipe the smile off my face once I got going on that bike! I actually rode 8 miles that day and burned almost 500 calories!”

It’s been really cool to connect with cast members from “Heavy.” (I’ve also traded a few emails with Jodi from episode one, which I’ll write more about soon.)

If there are any other “Heavy” cast members reading my blog, please comment or write me. I’m curious what you think.

Heavy: Episode 5

Mickey Goldmill, Rocky's "corner man"

When food is your "corner man," it never says, "You're a bum!"

Episode five of “Heavy” had the most ideal client pairing, Kevin, a 597 lb. 39-year-old father of three, and Flor, a 309 lb. 39-year-old mother of three. Besides being the same age, both had spouses and children who were also overweight. Both had families where food was an essential element of their bonding. And both had Type-2 diabetes. Kevin and Flor should have united over their commonalities, but from the beginning, they were on separate paths.

The episode began with Flor struggling to tie her shoes because her stomach, where she carried most of her weight, was so large. After giving birth to her three children and gaining more and more each time, she had reached a point where her day-to-day life was compromised. But it was a life Flor was comfortable with–she had accepted her fatness. Throughout her childhood, her mother constantly reminded her of it until Flor decided, “After hearing you’re fat so much, finally, it’s like, ‘Okay, okay I’m fat.’” She was molested by her stepfather as a young girl, driving her even closer to food, which became her source of comfort and safety. As a child, I felt the same as Flor. My father wasn’t in my life, and my mother, as a single mother, constantly worked, so when I needed someone, something, anything, there for me, it was food that filled the void. It became my best friend, my shoulder to cry on, my “corner man,” (Sorry to get all “Rocky” on you.), just as it had become for Flor. So, later in life, when her first marriage failed, food, again, was Flor’s support system. It was always there for her when she was most in need while simultaneously leading her down a road to a slow death, one she’d eventually have to walk with loose shoelaces. Now Flor was remarried and wanted to have another child with her husband, but her doctor strongly advised against it until she lost at least 70 lbs.

Like Flor, Kevin had always been fat. Throughout his childhood, he was called “Big Kev;” being big was who he was. It was part of his rep, something I can totally relate to as “a plate-cleaner” in my boyhood days–my plate and everyone else’s. Kevin’s weight was such a vital part of his identity that, according to his wife, he never really saw himself as overweight or obese. He just loved food and he didn’t know when to stop, but he knew his weight affected everyone in his family and was setting a bad example for his kids, who Kevin struggled to keep up with now. Kevin’s weight was also affecting his job as a high school sports coach. He couldn’t keep up there either and, again, was setting a bad example. He sweated profusely just barking out exercises to his team. As my overweight friend/personal trainer Carlos has told me many times, “Do what I say, not what I do.” Sometimes it just isn’t that easy though. Besides his weight, Kevin also had high blood pressure and sleep apnea, (And don’t forget that diabetes!) making it even more critical that he lose a significant amount of weight.

Pterodactyl

Pterodactyls may be extinct, but they live on through the sound of Flor vomiting.

Despite all they had in common, Flor and Kevin never jelled. Flor was determined; like Ashley, she was in beast-mode. Her first few days she puked her brains out (During her first round of vomiting, Flor sounded like a pterodactyl in heat and then popped her head up from the trash can smiling.), but she couldn’t be stopped, losing weight steadily, like Jessica, and building her belief in herself. When Flor earned a reward of a movie or a phone call, Flor chose the flick. (I really hope it was “Mi Vida Loca” because she looked particularly gangster with her head shaved and the doo-rag.) She was there for herself and was going to take the month and focus on her goal. It wasn’t an easy decision, but David the trainer reminded her, “In order to help your family, you need to help yourself first.”

Kevin, on the other hand, wavered. When he first arrived at “the facility,” David searched his bags and found Butterfingers, Blow Pops and other candy, which incensed him. By now, you may have noticed I have a hetero man-crush on David. (I called him a country of muscle last week.) Do not fuck with him. “Big Kev” learned that quickly when David immediately pulled him out of his room for a quick work out, telling Kevin as he began sweating it up, “No more candy. No more chocolate. We’re here for your family. We’re here for your kids. We’re here for your life. We’re here to make a change.” Kevin saw the results fast, too. His weight loss was rapid initially (21 lbs. in the first week and another 15 the second week), but then slowed, which was when David and Britny did a surprise search of Kevin’s room and found contraband, cookies. They do not mess around at “the facility,” and Kevin had reached his breaking point, leading to my favorite moment in the short television history of “Heavy” (Sorry, Rickywayne.): Kevin crying and blubbering like an overgrown baby, telling David and Britny, “The salad is getting on my nerves. I’m not going to eat the salad.” If this is not an Internet meme yet, it should be, and if you make one, please send it my way.

salad

Salad be tripping, yo. You don't even know.

After the first month, Flor and Kevin returned home and went in opposite directions. Kevin arrived home to pork chops–no more salad, or fish, which he didn’t eat either. He was eating less, but he wasn’t willing to give up the unhealthy food he always loved, leading to a first-week-away weight gain of 14 lbs. Britny visited immediately and couldn’t believe the reason Kevin gave her for his weight gain: “the Texas climate.” Yes, he blamed the humidity for his weight gain. Kevin began losing again, but it was clear that he was not completely committed to the regimen.

Flor struggled when coming home, too, gaining two lbs. in her first week. Her family wasn’t supportive of her weight loss, initially promising to go to the gym with Flor but not following through on it. Then beast-mode kicked in and she began tearing it up at the gym again–and at home, sitting her kids down and telling them they need to lose weight. My mother told me the same thing, but didn’t have Flor’s approach, constantly reminding me of my weight and then stuffing me with the wrong foods. Our vegetables came in cans or frozen boxes, and the crisper was where she stashed my two-liters of Sunkist, Coca-Cola, Mountain Dew and cream soda, which I went through at a one-bottle-per-day clip. Flor was straight-up with her kids though: “You have to make an effort of actually working out when we go as a family. Because I’m going to do it no matter if you guys do it or not.” Woah!

At the final weigh-in, Kevin walked in nervously. He had lost some weight, but he was the first client who didn’t look dramatically different than when he first arrived. When Kevin stepped on the scale, he weighed in at 507, a total of 90 lbs., which would have been a significant loss for anyone else; however, Kevin weighed in at 490 lbs., 17 lbs. lighter than his final weigh-in, only a month prior. David and Britny were supportive and encouraging, yet clearly disappointed. Losing 90 lbs. was a feat, though at Kevin’s weight, he should have lost more. I wouldn’t say he was a failure; however, Kevin was definitely the most likely client to gain the weight back. Like David told him, “You have a long way to go, and this is just the beginning.”

Flor was a different story; she waltzed in like a new woman with a stylish look and so much more energy. Her final weigh-in was 243, a total of 67 lbs. Although she lost less weight than Kevin, Flor had succeeded because she committed to a healthier lifestyle. She had become “a person who can accomplish anything [she] set [her] mind to.”

Flor and Kevin each represent exactly what can happen when a fat person attempts a significant weight loss. Like any addict, we reach rock bottom and make the commitment to change our lives. Sometimes, like in Flor’s case, we maintain that commitment for ourselves, or the pressure becomes too much, and we waver, like what happened with Kevin, losing a little here and there and then thinking we can cheat again.

People always say losing weight isn’t easy, but I disagree. Losing weight is easy. You eat less; you exercise more. Pretty simple. Keeping the weight off is the hard part. It requires a complete change in lifestyle. It means making time regularly for exercise, giving up some of the foods you love (You know my weakness for Haagen-Dazs already, but I should shout out my homies pizza, french fries and any sweets really except cheesecake.), and eating foods you might not love.

Like, salad.

Brian McGuigan is a writer, performer and arts get-shit-done-er working on a one-man show about his own struggles with weight loss entitled “Fat Fuck.” He’ll be blogging weekly about A&E’s new docu-drama “Heavy” on his blog brianwithani.com.

Hello, I Am Fat, Too, So, Of Course, You Want to Know What I Think…

This is exactly what I was thinking as I read Lindy West’s rebuttal to Dan Savage’s comments about fat people on the Slog Friday afternoon. Whenever something about fatness chubs out in the media, I’m often asked: What do you think, fat guy who writes about his fatness regularly? (Well, maybe not in those exact words.)

So rather than being asked at a party after I’ve had all too many beers–which is what happened on Friday night, and my response was, well, drunken–or by email (Sorry, I haven’t responded.) or over lunch at work, I figure I’ll tell you what I think here and forward the link on to anyone else who asks me about Lindy’s post.

Here goes:

Truffle Shuffle

No, I will not do the Truffle Shuffle for you. Sorry.

Fat people shouldn’t be shamed for our size–I can certainly agree with Lindy there. We shouldn’t be called fat fuck, fatty, fatso, lard ass, Chunk, Fat Albert, chubby, Sir Chubs-a-lot, Bubba, pudge muffin, Stay Puft Marshmellow Man (or Woman–for the equal opportunity fat-haters out there), Chubby Checker, Biggie Smalls, Cookie Monster, Tub-O-Lard, Tons of Fun, Whale, Elephant, Butterball, Butterbean, the Blob, Sugar Tits…. (I could go on forever, but here’s a running list to get your fill. Yes, fill.) We shouldn’t be teased into doing the Truffle Shuffle or have our rolls pinched in gym class or our hair pulled in the schoolyard. We shouldn’t be made to feel inadequate because of our girth or gross because we sweat more than the average person. There are so many shaming words and experiences scarring the collective consciousness of the fat that we should not have to endure simply because some skinny (In this case, Dan Savage, who puts fat fucks on a scale somewhere between pitbulls and pedophiles. (Just kidding, Dan. I know you were once fat, too.)) wants to make us feel smaller because of our largeness.

But where I disagree with Lindy is with the insinuation that because we’re shamed for being fat we are also oppressed. For oppression to truly exist, the oppressed are subjugated by force and lack the ability to enact change. Fat people have–sorry, Lindy, I have to say it–the right to make choices. We choose to eat excessively or not. We choose to hit the gym or walk on our lunch breaks or just sit our asses on the couch with those Doritos (Thanks to all that overtime!) and we most certainly choose to eat two burgers, onion rings and a black-and-white milkshake. Truly oppressed people lack choice. People of color can’t wash the pigment off their skin. Gay people can’t stop being attracted to the same sex. Mentally or physically disabled people can’t grow new brains or legs or arms. However, as fat people, we DO have power over our own bodies. We may be shamed, but to say we are oppressed is an insult to those who are really oppressed, who do not, in any way, have the ability to change. Lindy shouldn’t make oppression a buzz word in her personal struggle with fatness.

“Pretty much all of [fat people] have tried already [to lose weight]. A couple of them have succeeded. Whatever. My question is, what if they try and try and try and still fail? What if they are still fat? What if they are fat forever? What do you do with them then?” -Lindy West

Brian McGuigan in his fatter days.

Hey! That was me! (I'm the one on your left there.)

For the last month, I’ve been addicted to A&E’s “Heavy” (You can read my posts here, here, here and here. A post on last night’s episode is forthcoming.) where I’ve watched ten people who weigh far more than Lindy or me (Full disclosure: I currently weigh 242 lbs. and have weighed as much as 100 lbs. more and 40 lbs. less.), do exactly what Lindy says we can’t. They’ve all tried and failed and tried and failed, just like she and I have, until they had the proper guidance and, more importantly, the dedication to change their lives. Several of them still weigh more than we do, but they each have made the commitment, regardless of their jobs, families, schedules, etc., to make an effort to shed the shame they’ve been subjected to, the fear that made them believe they couldn’t do it, the anxiety that’s kept them up late at night wondering if they’ll ever be anything more than a fat fuck. I know it’s a TV show, but there are many more fat people out there, myself included, who have tried and failed and ultimately tried again and again. Defeatist attitudes, like Lindy’s, are common, but never help, yet somehow her justification-wrought post has received so much praise. Would you applaud a junkie who says, “I’m happy with who I am. I’ll shoot junk my whole life, and I don’t care what you think.”? I hope not.

No matter what size the tag says when we put our clothes on in the morning, we will always see a fat person when we look in the mirror. If we’ve been fat, we’ll see ourselves as fat forever, but only we can choose to let the world see us as otherwise. The walls of our lard prisons can shrink. We can climb over them. We can look in the mirror and say, “I have a problem, and I want to change.”

If Lindy is happy the way she is, I’m happy for her. When I was at my heaviest, I wasn’t happy. Then again, when I was at my lightest I wasn’t happy either. I’m happy now, right where I am because I’ve finally accepted that I have an unhealthy relationship with food and continuously address the reasons why. I have an addiction–it’s the first step in recovery.

But I want fat people to know that because Lindy failed to lose weight when she tried doesn’t mean that you, too, will fail. If you’re not happy, you can do it. You just have to be willing to try and fail and try again. Simply loving your body won’t make you lose weight, as Lindy suggests, but it may help you accept who you are, whatever size you are, and not use food as a mechanism of coping, which is what most fat people do. We get sad, so we eat, and then we feel bad that we’ve eaten, so we eat more to cope with our sadness. Trust me, you are not the only one.

And, finally, yes, thin isn’t better. Lindy’s right: losing weight won’t make you a real person or mean that you’ve succeeded as a woman or man. But healthy is better and being healthy will mean you’ll live longer and enjoy life more. (You probably know, but being fat can be pretty bad for you.) Lindy may or may not care about her health (Like she says, it’s none of anyone’s business.), but I care about mine.

Heavy: Episode 4

heart-shaped pizza

Pizza, when no one else loves me, I know you will.

Episode four, by far, is my least favorite “Heavy,” to date, for two reasons. 1) The show itself seemed to be missing something by skirting around the real issues of the clients, Lindy, a 285 lb. 37-year-old mother of two clearly suffering from a serious bout of depression after a divorce and lengthy custody battle, and Travis, a 432 lb. 34-year-old father of one (His wife gives birth to their second child 10 days into Travis’ stay at “the facility.), and 2) Both Lindy and Travis were most like me in terms of why they eat (depression, stress and reward), but least like me in terms of why they wanted to change their lifestyles. (They both claimed it was for their kids, but I don’t think either really had reasons.)

Before heading to “the facility,” Lindy knew she wasn’t happy. After seventeen years of marriage, she and her husband had divorced, and she promptly gained 175 lbs. Lindy’s children were embarrassed of her. She only saw them on weekends, and when she did see them, they wanted little to do with her. “Food is the only thing that loves me,” Lindy confessed, holding back the tears. Her mounting depression, which she described as “this whirlwind and [she] cannot find something to hold on to” (I’ve told my wife many times while struggling with my weight and depression caused by it that I’ve felt like a flag flapping in the wind. The images are so close it made me clam up.), is affecting her relationship with her fiance David, too, who’s getting calls while at work from Lindy almost weekly that caused him to be alarmed about her mental health. She would later admit to the therapist that she had contemplated suicide as her stress grew along with her waistline. Lindy could no longer manage; she was at her breaking point.

While Lindy’s weight came on in response to a traumatic event in her life, Travis has had a lifelong struggle with his weight. At the beginning of the episode, he spoke honestly about his plight as a fat person, saying, “We get depressed about how we feel and then we eat more to deal with that depression and then we get bigger, so we just get more depressed.” Thirty four years later, Travis tired easily due to his size, and as a father of one son with another on the way, he didn’t have the energy to keep up. His wife, nearly bursting with pregnancy, worried that she’d be a single mother if her husband didn’t change his life. She’s supportive but firm: Travis needed to lose weight now.

Upon arriving at “the facility,” neither Lindy nor Travis seemed like they really want to be there. Despite their reasons for wanting to get healthy before leaving home, they both had trouble accepting the regimen at “the facility.” During the first week, neither had the drive, complaining about the discomfort of the work outs and just not giving their all. About the only thing they were justified in complaining about was the food–not the quality, but the quantity; they were limited to 1200-2000 calories each day. I’ve always been against counting calories, so it’s hard for me to understand how a person could work out several hours each day and only eat 1200 calories. Considering Travis’ basal metabolic rate, or BMR, for short, which is basically the number of calories you burn if you stay in bed all day, he needed to eat almost 3500 calories just to maintain his weight. (You can check your own BMR here, by the way.) Cutting that down by two-thirds was extreme to me and somewhat explained why both he and Lindy were such complainers. But, as David the trainer, reminded us, “This is an addiction. They’re addicts, and going through withdrawals can get ugly.”

Lindy and Travis fed off of each other’s negativity, which both trainers continually called them on. At one point while working out, Travis joked that each day was one day closer to going home where he’d be able to eat ice cream again, a cringe-worthy moment for me because it showed that Travis didn’t really want to change his life. Again, David the trainer, whose body is a country of muscle, said it best, “If they don’t get rid of this negativity before they leave, they’re not going to be able to make a lifestyle change.”

bottom of an ice cream container

Rock bottom never tasted so damn good.

The negativity continued at Lindy’s first therapy session. She had trouble talking openly about her life, calling therapy “bullshit conversation.” As someone who’s been in therapy on and off for most of my life, I can understand where she is coming from. It’s a challenge to open up either because the wounds are so deep or the trust isn’t there yet. But, despite her reluctance to talk, Lindy began working even harder in the gym, exercising to the point of nearly passing out. Like me, she traded her obsession with food for an obsession with exercising, but, as Britny the trainer pointed out, without addressing the cause. When I first moved to Seattle, I didn’t even have a job, but knew I needed a gym membership as badly as I needed the Haagen-Dazs I craved in my teen years. So I headed to 24-Hour Fitness and plopped down my credit card for the most expensive membership package available, more than $600. I was working out two hours each day and had given up nearly every food I genuinely enjoyed. I was muscular and getting fit, yet absolutely miserable. It wasn’t until I found a therapist here and began working through the real issues causing me to eat that I saw the light at the bottom of the ice cream tub. Whether I was fat or fit, in the end, what mattered most was that I was happy. Lindy was dropping the weight, but I doubted she could say the same about herself.

Once Lindy and Travis left “the facility,” they both initially struggled to maintain their commitment to weight loss, as David suggested they would. Lindy continued to work hard, but due to the stress of trying to plan a wedding, began eating as a method of reward and a coping mechanism again. She and her fiance celebrated their engagement with a glass of wine, which turned into three bottles, and, as part of the wedding planning, they did a tasting, rotating samples of deliciously unhealthy cake, plates of foods and dips and glasses of fine wine. For a skinny person with a stable relationship with food, this wouldn’t be a problem, but for someone with a food addiction, cheating here and there quickly snowballs. Watching Lindy consistently cheat made me think: Who makes a commitment to someone else when they can’t even make a commitment to themselves? But after gaining a pound and a visit from Megan the nutritionist, Lindy was back on track. The slight weight gain helped her realize the importance of maintaining her diet.

While Lindy soared after the visit from Megan, Travis was crumbling. He wasn’t keeping his food log. He wasn’t maintaining his diet. He wasn’t working out as hard as he could. (The trainer at his hometown gym finally called him on it, and Travis recoiled even further, using his family life as an excuse for his lack of commitment.) Travis had finally reached his breaking point, and it all came to a head when he argued with his wife, who questioned his dedication to the regimen. Unable to accept any personal responsibility, Travis walked out on her, crying, “I’m done.”

And then came a visit from Britny, which, at first, Travis blew off. “Not today,” he insisted as he packed boxes for the family’s big move, yet another stressful undertaking that made me question Travis’ commitment. But Britny has a knack for talking down the big guys on “Heavy” (Remember: she turned Rickywayne from crazy to baby with one hug.) and soon Travis pledged to pull himself together, start keeping his food log again and work harder at the gym.

For the next month, Lindy and Travis were both recommitted. Lindy married her fiance, reducing some of her pre-wedding stress and allowing her to refocus on herself, and Travis found a job working at an appliance store, establishing a routine and keeping him on his feet. They both seemed happy and dedicated to the regimen.

At the final weigh-in, Travis and Lindy looked completely different. They weren’t rife with negativity like when they first arrived at “the facility” six months ago. And when they each hopped on the scale, I was impressed. Lindy weighed-in at 220 lbs., a total of 65 lbs. lost, and Travis weighed-in at 337.8, and after stripping off his pants and shoes because he was determined to break the 100 lb. mark, his weight was 333.6, a total of 99 lbs.

hamburger yo-yo

Yes, those are hamburger yo-yos. Don't they look delicious?

As impressed as I was though, I couldn’t deny that I was also concerned. Neither Lindy or Travis really addressed their core issues around their struggles with weight. They may look different now, but, unlike Ashley and Sharon of episode three, I didn’t feel either would be able to maintain their new lifestyles over the long term. Losing weight is the easy part; keeping the weight off is the hard part.

Having gained back more than half of the 140 lbs. I lost, I saw more of myself in Lindy and Travis than I wanted, yet I hoped neither would yo-yo like I did.

Brian McGuigan is a writer, performer and arts get-shit-done-er working on a one-man show about his own struggles with weight loss entitled “Fat Fuck.” He’ll be blogging weekly about A&E’s new docu-drama “Heavy” on his blog brianwithani.com.

Heavy: Episode 3

Dust-Off

Sure, it can get you high, but how can you put it on ice cream?

At the beginning of the second episode of “Heavy,” I was convinced the clients wouldn’t make it, but the third one had a different feel. It was more like an episode of Intervention, telling the back stories of the clients, Ashley, a 26-year-old alcoholic weighing in at 296 lbs, and Sharon, a 47-year old, 366-pound mother whose bipolar son had committed suicide only six months ago, as if their traumas were precisely the cause of their addictions (as is often the case with Intervention. After all, no one huffs Dust-Off or shoots up all day strictly out of boredom.) Because of their histories, both Ashley and Sharon were determined, and I could tell right away these two women would make it.

Before heading to “the facility,” we saw each nearly at rock bottom. Ashley had been drinking and partying five days a week for over a year and still lived with her father, who was also an alcoholic, and her stepmother, who, it turns out, was talking shit about Ashley once she left, saying she “wouldn’t change.”

Sharon was grieving through food. Her son’s suicide had affected her so deeply that she’d gained 60 lbs. in the last six months. Ten years before when her mother died, she gained 100. Eating was Sharon’s coping mechanism, and it helped her survive two of the most tragic moments a person can experience, the death of a parent and the death of a child.

Once arriving to “the facility,” Ashley and Sharon each talked honestly about their problems, why they were eating so much and not taking care of their bodies. Though they both struggled when they first began working out, neither seemed deterred. Sharon questioned herself, but wouldn’t stop working because she wanted to do right by her dead son. Plus she had Ashley in her corner, who was basically in beast mode. It happened quickly: on the first day while doing an ab work out Ashley began feeling queasy and soon vomited because she hadn’t had any alcohol. Ashley admitted to trainer Brittany that she was drinking regularly and knowing that her mother was a drug addict and her father was an alcoholic she accepted that she had a problem, too. And she never turned back.

Each pair of “Heavy” clients bonded on the previous two episodes, but Ashley and Sharon seemed to have a deeper connection. They were a good pair, a young woman who didn’t have the best childhood teamed with a middle-aged woman who just buried her son. In each other, they found what they lost or never had. Ashley and Sharon had a bond that made me jealous. I’ve had multiple work out partners in my life, Jay, who I mentioned last week, Ramon, my first work out partner in Weight Training class, and Chris Hillman, a college friend (and better known among my college buddies as “The Jew,” though technically he was only half-chosen). Jay, Ramon and Hillman were all supportive in their own ways. They all pushed me harder and were parts of my profound weight loss (about 140 lbs. if you didn’t already know), but none of these guys were ever fat like me. Ramon didn’t puke once the first week of class. Jay was into yoga and could bend his body in ways mine only experienced by eating pretzels. And Hillman was putting up weight plates I couldn’t even imagine. I still lost the weight, but it was a lonely road.

Marshawn Lynch

Ashley went all Marshawn Lynch on her waistline

Ashley and Sharon walked that road together, and at the one-month mark when they separated, Ashley 22 lbs. lighter and Sharon, 30, I felt even stronger: they were going to do it.  Ashley said it best, “Bring me more. What’s next?” And she wasn’t talking about the next course. I repeat: beast mode.

The toughest adjustment for Sharon outside of “the facility” was feeding herself. When walking through the grocery store with Megan the nutritionist, Sharon couldn’t believe how much a serving size of potatoes was (For the record, it’s the size of a computer mouse.) or that she couldn’t use her favorite ingredients–”butter, cinammon, sugar and marshmellows”–on them. Many Americans have little comprehension of proper food portions, or, like Sharon, find it hard to accept that foods lower in fat can still have flavor. At my heaviest, I was consuming enough calories each day for two and thought because I drank Sunny Delight and starved myself occasionally after a day of intense eating that I was healthy enough. When I finally decided it was time to lose weight, I knew exercise was only part of the equation. Fueling my body properly was the other. I had to make adjustments in my diet. Despite her initial reluctance, Sharon made the adjustments, too, (There’s a particularly funny scene where David the trainer does a house inspection and finds an apple pie, but it’s a fake one filled with potpourri.) and wouldn’t allow herself to fail. She made her weight loss a memorial to her dead son, and with the confidence she built over her the month at “the facility,” Sharon knew full well: “I can do this. I’m really going to make it.”

Mouse

Potatoes taste better, I promise.

By far, Ashley was the most determined client to date. Upon arriving home, she admitted to her friends that she had a drinking problem and asked that they not invite her out to drink or party. Quickly, Ashley learned who her true friends were and didn’t let the lost relationships affect her. Within two weeks, she and her sister had moved out of their parents’ house because Ashley couldn’t deal with her father’s drinking and poor eating habits. She was surrounded by enablers but had the perseverance to continue working out, eating healthy, taking care of herself. Though she vowed not to return to bartending, the money and tips were hard to pass up, especially now that she was out on her own, yet her will power never wavered. Ashley stayed on course; truly, she was an inspiration.

But the best part of the third episode wasn’t Ashley’s killer instinct, it was Sharon, who, at “the facility” couldn’t even get her feet into the strapped pedals of a spin bike, finally made it on a bicycle, riding around her neighborhood with her daughter and Brittany. The look on Sharon’s face could only be described in one word: victorious. She conquered her grief, her addiction, herself. “I feel changed from the inside out,” Sharon said, and that’s really what weight loss is all about. It’s not staring in the mirror and seeing a thinner face, less Oprah around the arms or tire around the waist–losing weight is changing your belief system, realizing that what you thought about yourself, what other people said about you your whole life and internalized wasn’t true. This was, perhaps, the most difficult challenge for me. I could work out. I could change the way I ate, but when I put my head on the pillow at night, I still wasn’t happy. I didn’t believe yet.

After six months, it was clear that Ashley and Sharon definitely changed from inside out, and when they walked into “the facility” on the 180th day, the change was seen on the outside, too. Ashley, whose final weigh-in was 205, a total of 91 lbs., and Sharon, whose weigh-in was 255, a total of 110 lbs., were all new women. Like Ashley said, “I’m not stopping. I’m strong enough to continue to do this… and reach the goals I want to reach.”

She makes it sound so easy.

Brian McGuigan is a writer, performer and arts get-shit-done-er working on a one-man show about his own struggles with weight loss entitled “Fat Fuck.” He’ll be blogging weekly about A&E’s new docu-drama “Heavy” on his blog brianwithani.com.